Andrew Allison

Sana Ali Comments

In Uncategorized on May 16, 2007 at 6:35 pm

Well, I have been unavailable to blog for the last two days, but I have been noticing what is happening in the comments section on Sana Ali. When I wrote that post I did not expect it to be a speculation forum on Islam, was it an honour killing or not, and the treatment of Muslim women. I wrote it to highlight a tragic event. A young life cut short. I will not put on comment moderation, however it would be good to remember a person has been murdered and stop throwing around punches at each other.

Advertisements
  1. I hear you Andrew, but that’s what you’ll get for posting on those things 😦

    Most authorities now believe this to be an ‘honour’ killing, doesn’t make it so but that is where they are going with it.

    It’s a tragedy no matter WHY it happened, it’s a tragedy BECAUSE it happened. But the real tragedy is that it never HAD to happen.

  2. I completely agree and apologise on my part.

    however, i would ask one of your commenters, Ruthie, to learn abit more about “islam” rather than talk to people she feels represent “Islam”. not all muslims follow or understand islam, unfortunately.

  3. Yes, it got a bit heated on your previous post, didn’t it? But that’s what blogging’s about. You are right: let us reflect upon the tragedy of a young life lost.

  4. Hate to go in a different direction…

    Sofi, it is not up to Ruthie to learn more, it is up to the Muslims to stop the people that commit these and other terrible acts from ‘hijacking’ your religion.

    They are the voices that are loud and heard, it is no wonder that many believe them.

  5. >>Sofi, it is not up to Ruthie to learn more, it is up to the Muslims to stop the people that commit these and other terrible acts from ‘hijacking’ your religion.

    while i appreciate your comments, it turns out the woman charged for her murder is in fact a sikh. would ruthie’s comments stand now, i wonder? and i disagree with your comments – we’re all responsible to learn and counteract our own ignorance. as for the latter part of your comment – i complete disagree again as i dont believe they commit evil acts in the name of Islam; its more to appease a sadistic human nature than anything else, in my opinion.

    sensational news sells- but oh please, open our eyes and realise there is more than what we read/hear of in the media.

  6. On a update on this a Sikh Girl has been setup by the Muslim family for this case so they dont get caught she has been blamed police have charged her BUT the only evidence they go is that she seen Sana that day and she has no alibi. She was trapped after having being courted by the husband of Sana….

  7. ^^^^^uh what utter nonsense you do not get charged for murder and refused bail just because you have no alibi!!!!!! At some point during the investigation something must have been found, fingerprints, hair strand etc, on the body, maybe sana said something on the way to hospital, as she was still alive when found. And how exactly do you know the family is at fault, the husband has been released and somebody on the other topic says there is proof that he wasn’t there!?

    Either way this girl looks to be in a real predicament, and you have to ask why was she there in the first place!? I agree something seems amiss to me, but somebody deserves to pay for the crime that has been commited!

  8. Yeh i heard it was a setup too, thats what all the peep saying in Manchester… think we’ll find out soon enough

  9. Its amazing that all these people seem to know the “facts” like it was a setup by the family etc. This is all pure speculation and anyone can start a rumour that become a “fact” after three of four people have heard it.

    A woman and her unborn child have died. We should remember that. Let the police do their job and the true facts will come out in time.

  10. Good heavens.

    I suspect I know a great deal more about Islam than any of your commenters think I do. I am not ordinarily one to be judgmental or speak strongly, in fact, quite the opposite (ask LN).

    The truth defends itself. Honor killings are particular to Islam. There isn’t much more to say.

    It’s a tragedy that this woman lost her life.

  11. Ruthie dear you dont know a thing about religion. It’s like my saying paedophilia is particular to Christianity as the Catholic church divulged and in some cases accepted this abuse. Your argument is just as silly and pathetic.

    I would suggest you actually learn something than assumptions. I love the “I’m not racist. I have black friends” line. Try something different.

  12. Christianity, on the other hand, says: “Do not revenge yourselves. Vengeance is mine, saith the Lord.”

    Better to leave it to the Big Boy to deal with.

  13. “Ruthie dear you dont know a thing about religion. It’s like my saying paedophilia is particular to Christianity as the Catholic church divulged and in some cases accepted this abuse. Your argument is just as silly and pathetic.

    I would suggest you actually learn something than assumptions. I love the “I’m not racist. I have black friends” line. Try something different.”

    Summed up as pfft

  14. nazh your post is just bollox. Jewish paedophile in India caught today. lets blame the Israelites what ya say?

  15. Was it an Israelite that did it? If so, then by all means, blame him.

    When a terrorist screams out Long Live Israel before bombing a group of civilians in east Jordan, then I’ll get to condeming the Jewish terrorists.

    Andrew: Sorry to hijack the thread, carry on 😦

  16. Hebron is fine though yeah? you are brain washed.

    The whole country, including Ben Hurian is classified as a terrorist by none other than your best pal UK. How often does George Bush blow up Jack Chirac’s home?

  17. Juvenile attacks on my character amuse me.

    I’m not even getting involved in this ridiculous argument, especially with someone who doesn’t have the balls to leave their name.

  18. I am putting comment moderation back on again. Please feel free to comment, and although I have never deleted a comment on my blog before, I will if the comments start getting abusive

  19. guys this blog has been opened so we can all put our comments on it……2 say how sorry we are for all these deaths which are takin place in all around the world……not bcuz we need 2 tell each other how rong their culture,tradition or religion is….!theres no Race….! things happen…and there has to be a reason for somthin 2 happen…..when i came on this side i thot how lucky sana is but after readin all the comments its more like what u ppl think abt religions….2 u tht matters the most…u guys r blamin each other…i’m related 2 sana…..n i kno wat her family is goin thru…..i hope whoevr it was family or no family….shud get wat they deserve….!i hpe they understand whats comin 2 em…..i hope she rests in peace…….

  20. “Juvenile attacks on my character”

    what a clown. What about the attacks on all the muslims, billions on this earth. They apparently are commanded by god to kill their wives. I’m certainly not the Juvenile here!

  21. Thanks for article!

  22. Thanks for interesting article.

  23. Glad to read articles like this. Thanks to author!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: